Marty McDaniel, CHA
Why the pursuit of exceptional hotel investments can cause investors to overlook good assets that experienced operators can transform into great performers.
There is a deal that never gets made in this business. It is not necessarily a bad deal, nor is it particularly risky. It is simply a good opportunity that fails to look exceptional on the opening slides of an investment committee presentation. The location is respectable rather than fashionable. The rooms need attention. The trailing financial performance is inconsistent. The brand may have lost some of its appeal. Someone circles a few figures in red, the opportunity is marked as a pass, and the search for something better continues.
I often wonder how many opportunities we dismiss without examining what they could become.
We have become remarkably sophisticated at evaluating hotel investment opportunities. We have financial models, market rankings, data rooms, dashboards and enough comparative statistics to make almost any acquisition appear scientific. These tools are valuable. I use them myself, and I would never advocate committing capital without rigorous underwriting. But there is a fundamental difference between using information to understand an asset and allowing information to make the entire investment decision.
One approach tells us what a hotel has been. The other asks what it could become, what investment would be required to get it there, who has the experience and capability to execute the strategy, and how much of that potential upside is already reflected in the purchase price.
Those are fundamentally different investment questions, and recognising the distinction can be the difference between overlooking a good asset and identifying an exceptional opportunity.
The Premium For Looking Perfect
Consider two hotels operating in the same broad market. The first appears to tick almost every box: a strong brand, recent renovation, clean financial records, a recognisable location and consistently good reviews. It is the property everyone likes at first glance. It is also the one every other investor can recognise. That appeal is usually reflected in the asking price. When the seller has already completed much of the improvement work, the buyer may effectively be paying today for a substantial part of tomorrow’s anticipated success.
The second hotel comes with a few more imperfections. Its room rates lag behind the competitive set. The public spaces look dated, and its staffing structure has remained largely unchanged for years. It does not photograph nearly as well. Yet it sits close to established sources of demand, has a fundamentally sound physical structure and may be available at a price that leaves sufficient room for a properly costed improvement plan. It may never win the beauty contest, but it could win the investment contest.
These are illustrative comparisons, not an argument that every ageing or underperforming hotel represents a bargain. Some weaknesses are permanent. A poor location cannot be rescued by a redesigned lobby. An inefficient building layout, an unmanageable franchise obligation or a structural demand problem can quickly erode the advantage of an attractive purchase price. Experience is not a licence to overlook the numbers; it is what enables an investor to distinguish a manageable weakness from a fundamental flaw.
The wider market also deserves consideration. JLL reported that US hotel transaction volume reached US$24 billion in 2025, an increase of 17.5 per cent over the previous year. This demonstrates renewed capital activity, but it does not mean every sought-after acquisition is sensibly priced or that the most attractive opportunity is necessarily the property with the fewest visible imperfections. In a competitive investment market, the premium attached to a hotel that already looks perfect can sometimes leave less room for the buyer to create additional value.
The View From The Lobby Is Different
A hotel is not a bond, a warehouse or a spreadsheet with a flag on the roof. It is an operating business that happens to own or occupy real estate. Every day, people show up, guests make decisions, equipment works or fails, and revenue either converts into profit or leaks away through a hundred small operational habits. That is where a significant part of the investment story lives.
You can see a weak operating margin in a report. What you cannot necessarily see from the report alone is whether the cause is poor scheduling, an ineffective general manager, an expensive distribution mix, a property that is underpriced on high-demand nights, or maintenance that has been deferred for so long that it has become a capital issue. The remedy matters as much as the symptom.
The American Hotel & Lodging Association’s 2026 survey identified labour costs, supplies, utilities and insurance among the pressures facing hotel owners. HVS has similarly warned that revenue growth is no longer enough, by itself, to offset rising operating costs and protect hotel profitability.
This is not an academic distinction. If expenses rise faster than revenue, a perfectly respectable RevPAR story can still conceal a disappointing return for the owner.
Years ago, researchers studying 98 full-service hotels found a meaningful relationship between employee turnover and gross operating profit. The lesson is not that an investor should buy any hotel with staffing problems. Rather, it is that what happens in the back office, the laundry room and the morning line-up can reach all the way into the value of the real estate.
This is where people who have actually run hotels earn their seat at the investment table. They know when an expense line is genuinely lean and when it is simply starved. They can distinguish between an underperforming sales effort and a market with no business left to capture. They understand that replacing the carpeting is not the same as fixing the product, and that adding labour is not the same as improving service.
Think About The House, Not Just The Listing
Most people understand this instinctively in other areas of life. Think about buying a house. The immaculate property on the corner has been freshly painted, carefully staged and photographed to perfection. It attracts ten bidders. Down the block is a structurally sound house with dated kitchen cabinets and an unattractive light fixture. A buyer who understands construction can estimate the renovation costs, assess the neighbourhood and sometimes identify a better long-term purchase. The objective is not to fall in love with a fixer-upper. It is to understand which imperfections are cosmetic, which are expensive and which cannot be corrected at any price.
Consider a restaurant. A beautiful dining room, expensive signage and a long reservation list do not guarantee that the kitchen can deliver a profitable menu on a busy Saturday. Meanwhile, an unremarkable neighbourhood restaurant with loyal customers and disciplined food costs may have greater economic substance than its décor suggests. You need the financial statements, but you also need someone who understands the business behind them.
Even sport offers an obvious comparison. There is a difference between signing the player with the most impressive highlight reel and recognising the one who fits your system, responds to coaching and makes the people around him better. The most impressive résumé does not always produce the best team.
Talent, fit and execution matter, and the person making the judgement must understand the game.
We should be just as willing to apply that common sense to hotel investments.
The Deal Nobody Wants To Explain
Here is the uncomfortable part: a great-looking deal is often easier to defend in an investment meeting than a good asset supported by a thoughtful operating thesis. Nobody is likely to face much criticism for recommending an attractive property in a strong market with excellent historical performance. Every chart confirms what the room already wants to believe. The purchase price may be aggressive, but the investment story feels safe.
A less polished opportunity requires someone to stand up and explain precisely why performance is lagging, how it can be improved, how long the process will take and what happens if the plan falls short. It demands accountability. You cannot hide behind a market ranking when the real value depends on hiring the right general manager, strengthening the sales effort, resetting the revenue strategy or completing a renovation without putting cash flow under unnecessary pressure.
That discomfort can become an organisational bias. The investment committee ends up selecting what is easiest to approve rather than what is most likely to deliver an attractive risk-adjusted return. And when nearly every buyer applies similar investment criteria, it should come as little surprise that the same supposedly exceptional assets attract the greatest competition.
There is a useful irony here. CBRE’s 2025 US Hotel Investor Intentions Survey found that 77 per cent of respondents were targeting value-add and opportunistic investments. In other words, much of the market says it wants assets it can improve. Yet, in practice, investors sometimes insist that an opportunity arrive with so much uncertainty already removed that very little improvement potential remains to be acquired at a reasonable price.
The challenge is not simply finding an asset with room for improvement; it is being prepared to explain and take responsibility for the strategy required to unlock that value.
The most important underwriting question may be less glamorous than the presentation suggests: What can we change, what will that change cost, and who has successfully done it before?
Bring The Operator Into The Room Earlier
I am not suggesting that hotel veterans possess some mystical ability that makes them immune to bad decisions. We have all seen experienced professionals overpay for an asset, misread a market or convince themselves they can fix something that is fundamentally broken. Familiarity can create blind spots just as easily as an overly sophisticated financial model can. Judgement must always be tested through challenge, documentation and discipline.
But an operating perspective should not be invited into the conversation only after an investment committee has decided which assets deserve serious attention. That expertise belongs at the beginning: on the first property visit, during the initial examination of the profit and loss statement, when assessing the competitive set, and in the discussion about what a credible first 100 days would look like.
Let the analyst interrogate the assumptions. Let the lender stress-test the debt service. Let the engineer price the deferred maintenance. Let the operator explain whether the promised improvement is achievable with the building, workforce, brand and local market that actually exist. Then make the decision together.
McKinsey has recently described a broader shift in real estate towards returns created through asset-level execution rather than simply benefiting from rising market valuations. That may sound like consulting language, but the underlying idea is straightforward and decidedly old-fashioned: buying well matters; running well matters just as much.
In hotel investment, those two disciplines were never meant to be separated.
Good Is A Starting Point, Not An Apology
A good deal should never be code for settling. It should mean the asset has sound underlying economics, its downside can be understood, the cost of correcting its weaknesses can be measured, and the purchase price leaves a sensible margin for both execution risk and potential reward.
A great deal, by contrast, is not necessarily the asset with the most impressive brochure. It is the one that proves its value to the owner after the closing, the capital calls, the budget meetings and the occasional difficult trading season.
I would much rather see an investment committee debate a hotel that needs work but is available at a defensible price than readily approve a flawless-looking property whose investment case depends on an already excellent operation somehow becoming even better. The first may offer controllable upside. The second may leave very little room for error.
We should keep the data. We should keep the discipline. We should continue asking difficult questions. But we must also remember what all those numbers are intended to describe: an actual hotel, serving actual guests, in an actual market and operated by actual people.
Sometimes, the greatest investment opportunity is not the deal that checks every box, but the good asset whose potential others have failed to recognise.
It is the opportunity that someone with the right experience, sound judgement and operational capability knows how to turn into something great.
About The Author
Marty McDaniel, CHA, is a second-generation hotelier with 38 years of experience across hotel ownership, development, operations and advisory. His background includes more than 25 renovations and 12 ground-up projects. He currently serves as Chief Executive Officer and Managing Member of The Northstar Companies, LLC. His writing focuses on the practical judgement, investment discipline and operating decisions that determine long-term hospitality asset value.
JLL
— “Hotel Investment Momentum Builds as U.S. Market Posts $24 Billion in 2025 Transaction Volume” (30 January 2026).
American Hotel & Lodging Association
— “Rising Costs, Staffing Challenges Persist for Hotels as Travel Demand Expected to Hold Steady” (17 March 2026).
HVS
— “Hotel Profitability in Transition: Cost Pressures and Budgeting Priorities for 2026” (19 December 2025).
Cornell University — Tony L. Simons and Timothy R. Hinkin
— “The Effect of Employee Turnover on Hotel Profits,” Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly (August 2001).
Discover more from Tourism Reporter
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


